Why Fabrication Drawings Get Rejected: 10 Common Reasons

Wrong dimensions, a lack of coordination and details, and not adhering to project needs. The result? An ultimate rejection of fabrication drawings. Fabrication detail thus stands as an essential part for incurring a conversion of structural design intent into an accurate set of buildable steel components. However, the drawings, which are far more intricate at a technical level, need far more understanding. 

Thus, comprehending these common issues can assist engineers, along with fabricators and respective project teams, to reduce the risk and enhance the approval rates of drawings. At Structive, our core steel detailing services offer an emphasis on producing well-coordinated and fabrication-ready documentation that aptly supports constructability and accuracy, thereby driving a feasible execution of the project.

Table of Contents 

  • Why are steel connection details rejected in shop drawings?
  • How to fix wrong weld symbols in steel shop drawings?
  • What causes bolt hole and edge distance errors in drawings?

Why are steel connection details rejected in shop drawings?

At Structive, we demonstrate that the steel connection detailings can actually be rejected especially when drawings involve incorrect connection to either geometry or include missing dimensions or even unsuitable arrangements of bolts of details that do not properly correspond with the approved structural design. 

Therefore, the information related to connections should be transparent enough for fabrication and erection teams to leverage an interpretation without unnecessary assumptions.

Common reasons involve: 

  • Incorrect level of connection dimensions: This involves member sizes along with respective dimensions or connection locations which may not match the key design 
  • Missing information of connection: Core important bolts along with plates and even welds or stiffeners may be omitted 
  • Mismatch of design detailings: The hop drawing may primarily differ from the core engineer approved connection 
  • Poor coordination: The connection details may conflict with key beams along with columns and even braces or other building elements 
  • Unclear annotations: Incomplete notes can make respective fabrication needs which are complex to interpret

Thus an accurate level of structural steel detailing assists in connecting the intent of engineering with practical level of fabrication needs while reducing avoidable revisions. 

How to fix wrong weld symbols in steel shop drawings?

At Structive, we portray that the correcting weld symbols begins with checking with the drawing against the applicable range of design needs along with core welding specifications and an approved level of connection detailings. Further a wrong weld symbol can communicate an incorrect level of weld type, along with location or size and thus potentially creating fabrication and corresponding inspection issues.

Before issuing upon revised drawings, here are the key aspects to verify:

  1. Weld placement along with symbol orientation 
  2. Required level of size and the type of weld 
  3. Weld locations against the respective connection geometry 
  4. Design notes followed by welding specifications 
  5. Consistency between the pans along with elevations and even sections and connection detailings

A structured level of checking procedure can prevent repeated level of revisions and make the corresponding steel fabrication drawings clearer for shop floor teams.

What causes bolt hole and edge distance errors in drawings?

At Structive, we signify that the edge distance along with bolt hole errors are being addressed through a detailed level of dimensional checks followed by connection coordination and model based verification before drawings actually reach upon the fabrication.

Issues can come into play when bolt layouts are being copied incorrectly, member dimensions particularly change without any corresponding updates or even minimum edge distances are overlooked.

Common Errors 

Reason It Matters 

Recommended Check 

Incorrect size of bolt hole 

May prevent proper level of bolt installation 

Verify upon hole and bolt specifications 

Insufficient level of edge distance 

Can actually affect connection performance and core fabrication 

Check the needful minimum distances 

Incorrect spacing associated with bolt 

May conflict with connection needs 

Comparing upon layout with approved detailings 

Misaligned bolt holes 

Can create upon erection difficulties 

Coordinate connected members 

Missing holes 

Can need upon costly site modifications 

Reviewing upon sections along with plans and respective connection detailings 

These respective issues thus demonstrate as in why steel shop drawing connection and bolt hole errors should thus be recognised during detailing rather than after the beginning of fabrications.

Improve Drawing Accuracy With Professional Steel Detailing With Structive 

Even small mistakes can lead to fabrication drawing rejections, which sometimes cause major issues during the fabrication or erection process. Among other possible causes of drawing rejection are incorrect weld symbols, bolt-hole positions, either incomplete joints or coordination matters. Each of these errors requires thorough verification.

In case you want to know what the common reasons steel fabrication drawings get rejected

If you simply require a comprehensive approach to preparing correct documentation, you can rely on Steel Detailing Services to provide expert support in terms of obtaining high-quality drawings, precise information about fabrication, and minimizing unnecessary revisions.

Contact Structive and choose our services when searching for coordinated detailing, timely documentation, or ready-to-fabricate structural information.

FAQs

What are ways to avoid bolt-hole mistakes?

One way to eliminate bolt-hole mistakes is by conducting regular dimensional tests, coordinating construction details and validating the models.

The answer is yes. A well-coordinated 3D model can enable the identification of conflicts, non-conformities and geometry problems long before fabrication documents are produced.

Before sending a drawing for fabrication, it is essential to verify: dimensions, sizes of sections, connection data, welding symbols, bolt layout, distance between holes from the edges of the respective plates, and information about the material.